Digital Campus podcast: "Wikipedia: Friend or Foe"

16 March 2007 by sage

GMU’s Center for History and New Media has a new podcast that launched a week and a half ago: Digital Campus.

It’s “A biweekly discussion of how digital media and technology are affecting learning, teaching, and scholarship at colleges, universities, libraries, and museums”, and the first episode is on Wikipedia.

The intro music is worth listening to. After that, I recommend skipping to 17:33, when the Wikipedia discussion begins.

What you would be skipping includes:

  • Vague speculation about Windows Vista
  • Banter about the value and limitations of Google Docs
  • Hand-wringing about a recently granted overly broad patent for Blackboard Inc.

Wikipedia topics include:

  • Mills Kelly explaining why he is using Wikipedia as the “textbook” for his Western Civ course this semester
  • The similarity between constructing knowledge on Wikipedia an in scholarly venues, as revealed by those pages “hidden” behind the articles
  • How Citizendium’s name is crappy, and how in the end scholars are going to have to “roll up their sleeves and just get involved with the main Wikipedia” to set things straight
  • How scholars write for themselves and their peers too often, when they should be engaged with and teaching their students about the “enthusiast communities” like Wikipedia
  • What Wikipedia could do better to work with the professional community
  • “Specialized wikis for specialized topics in specialized communities” and the ways Wikipedia (and it’s pitfalls) may overshadow the wiki technologies
  • Friend-or-foe conclusion: “sometimes unreliable, sometimes stands you up, but good friend”

Overall, it’s pretty good.

(via T. Mills Kelly at edwired)

Possibly related posts:

  1. Superb Wikipedia podcast; Ideas for Wikipedia to steal
  2. Wikipedia in the classroom
  3. More scholars calling for Wikipedia involvement
  4. On Wikipedia burnout and hostility toward expertise
  5. The Future of Wikipedia (my take), part 2

Posted in Wikipedia, edtech, garden-variety history, podcast, teaching | 1 Comment »

One Response to “Digital Campus podcast: "Wikipedia: Friend or Foe"”

  1. LINKSHARE LEADS says:

    Saw your blog listed at blogsearch.sg Thank you!

leave a comment

recent comments

  • sage: Peter, I’m not interested in having this argument. It was interesting to me 4 years ago when I started, but all the points...
  • Peter Damian (banned editor): >>Wikipedia’s virtues far outweigh its faults, in my view But please give arguments. The page you...
  • sage: There is some validity to each of these points, of course, but you’re not raising any issues Wikipedians haven’t...
  • Peter Damian (banned editor): You haven’t answered his objection. Everything I have read by Cade seems like whole truth to me. I...
  • Peter Damian (banned editor): The main criticisms are 1. That a list of facts is not the same as a fact. 2. That by some magic having...

Popular Posts

archives

categories

ragesoss dents

  • RT@feministhulk: HULK THINK DONNA HARAWAY IS THE BEE'S KNEES. CHALLENGE HULK TO CONSIDER TECHNO-POLITICS OF HIS BIG GREEN BODY. - July 26th, 2010 at 4:13 PM
  • RT@phoebe R.I.P. Daniel Schorr. I listened to your NPR broadcasts my entire life, and you made the news humane. http://n.pr/byFI8D - July 24th, 2010 at 2:53 PM
  • I just discovered http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/ Outstanding! - July 22nd, 2010 at 11:08 AM
  • Interesting read: http://ur1.ca/0rw4w The article argues that it's human nature to double down on wrong "facts" you know when challenged. - July 20th, 2010 at 4:15 PM
  • The spam comments on my blog are really affirming and complimentary today. You're welcome, spambots! I'm glad I could brighten your day! - July 19th, 2010 at 3:10 PM
  • For all the doubters: yes, Ceiling Cat is real. http://ur1.ca/0ph5t - July 17th, 2010 at 2:15 PM

follow me on Identi.ca
www.flickr.com
ragesoss' items go to Sage's photostream

free culture

history of science, etc.

miscellanea

ragesoss feeds