Filed under: Citizendium

Citizendium struggles to reach critical mass

July 20th, 2007

I’ve been keeping my eye on Citizendium, watching as the edit rate dwindles and the policy discussion about licensing stagnates. I hoped that Citizendium would help establish the legitimacy of experts contributing to the work of open content, and that it develop a mutually beneficial relationship with Wikipedia.

Unfortunately, it seems like Citizendium has missed its chance, and is slowly fading out. I’ve drafted an article for the Wikipedia Signpost, analyzing Citizendium’s current status and comparing the 31 Approved articles they’ve produced to the corresponding Wikipedia content. Any comments and criticisms to help me improve it before I head off to visit my families across the country (beginning this Saturday) would be greatly appreciated.

Posted in Citizendium, Wikipedia | 13 Comments »

recent comments

  • Nihiltres: I’ve experienced an interesting counterexample. I was given a pirate copy of “Minecraft” by my younger...
  • sage: I’m not trying to justify copyright infringement, which certainly can harm creators in many cases. But it’s a lot more...
  • Jason Waggoner: Actually, they are both theft, strictly speaking. In the first scenario, you are technically robbing the copywrite owners...
  • Darryl: There’s no mention of what might be the one best feature of Vignette, that you can set it to save the original unprocessed...
  • Rami: The problem for me is that the app takes on its own look and feel rather than being similar to the stock android app with added...

Popular Posts

archives

categories

ragesoss dents

  • But when many anecdotes complement each other, and editors pull that out, you get something cool that no current review database can match. - January 28th, 2012 at 8:46 PM
  • As I imagine it, wiki-like curation would be an important element. Amazon reviews are useful not just for ave. stars, but anecdotes. - January 28th, 2012 at 8:42 PM
  • RT@evan Someday knowing the ins and outs of copyright will be like knowing the intricate rules of internal passports in Communist East ... - January 28th, 2012 at 8:10 PM
  • Federation makes a lot of sense... pre-existing communities centered on X (e.g., Android devices) just set up an instance and federate in. - January 28th, 2012 at 8:06 PM
  • Cool! My development skills are minimal, but I'm trying to pick up Django by building a rudimentary review site. - January 28th, 2012 at 8:04 PM
  • Why we need a free culture, community-run review site, independent of any merchant: http://ur1.ca/7x7cn Anybody want to start one with me? - January 28th, 2012 at 12:39 PM

follow me on Identi.ca
www.flickr.com
ragesoss' items go to Sage's photostream

free culture

history of science, etc.

miscellanea

ragesoss feeds