7 May was the 50th anniversary of C. P. Snow‘s famous lecture The Two Cultures. Snow, a novelist who had studied science and held technology related government positions, decried the cultural rift between scientists and literary intellectuals. Snow’s argument, and his sociopolitical agenda, were complex (read the published version if you want the sense of it; educational reform was the biggie), but, especially post-“Science Wars”, the idea of two cultures resonates beyond its original context. The current version of the Wikipedia article says:
The term two cultures has entered the general lexicon as a shorthand for differences between two attitudes. These are
- The increasingly constructivist world view suffusing the humanities, in which the scientific method is seen as embedded within language and culture; and
- The scientific viewpoint, in which the observer can still objectively make unbiased and non-culturally embedded observations about nature.
That’s a distinctly 1990s and 2000s perspective.
Snow’s original idea bears only scant resemblance to the scientism vs. constructivism meaning. As he explained, literary intellectuals (not entirely the same thing as humanities scholars) didn’t understand basic science or the technology-based socioeconomic foundations of modern life, and they didn’t care to. Novelists, poets and playwrights, he complained, didn’t know the second law of thermodynamics or what a machine-tool was, and the few that did certainly couldn’t expect their readers to know.
Humanistic studies of science (constructivist worldview and all) would have undermined Snow’s argument, but humanists were only just beginning to turn to science as a subject for analysis. (Kuhn’s Structure of Scientific Revolutions was not until 1962. Structure did mark the acceleration of sociological and humanistic studies of science, but was actually taken up more enthusiastically by scientists than humanists. Widespread constructivism in the humanities only became common by the 1980s, I’d guess, and the main thrust of constructivism, when described without jargon, is actually broadly consistent with the way most scientists today understand the nature of science. It’s not nearly so radical as the popular caricature presented in Higher Superstition and similar polemics.) Rather than humanists understanding the scientific method or scientists viewing their work through a sociological or anthropological lens, Snow’s main complaint was that scientific progress had left the slow-changing world of literature and its Luddite inhabitants behind (and hence, scientists found little use for modern literature).
Snow wrote that “naturally [scientists] had the future in their bones.” That was the core of the scientific culture, and the great failing of literary culture.
Looking back from 2009, I think history–and the point in it when Snow was making his argument–seems very different than it did to Snow. Who, besides scientists, had the future in their bones in 1959? In the 1950s academic world, literature was the pinnacle of ivory tower high culture. Not film, not television, certainly not paraliterary genres like science fiction or comic books. History of science was a minor field that had closer connections to science than to mainstream history.
Today, in addition to scientists, a whole range of others are seen as having “the future in their bones”: purveyors of speculative fiction in every medium; web entrepreneurs and social media gurus; geeks of all sorts; venture capitalists; kids who increasingly demand a role in constructing their (our) own cultural world. The modern humanities are turning their attention to these groups and their historical predecessors. As Shakespeare (we are now quick to note) was the popular entertainment of his day, we now look beyond traditional “literary fiction” to find the important cultural works of more recent decades. And in the popular culture of 1950s through to today, we can see, perhaps, that science was already seeping out much further from the social world of scientsts themselves than Snow and other promoters of the two cultures thesis could recognize–blinded, as they were, by the strict focus on what passed for high literature.
Science permeated much of anglophone culture, but rather than spreading from high culture outward (as Snow hoped it might), it first took hold in culturally marginal niches and only gradually filtered to insulated spheres of high culture. Science fiction historians point to the 1950s as the height of the so-called “Golden Age of [hard] Science Fiction”, and SF authors could count on their audience to understand basic science. Modern geek culture–and its significance across modern entertainment–we now recognize, draws in part from the hacker culture of 1960s computer research. Feminists and the development of the pill; environmentalists; the list of possible examples of science-related futuremaking goes on and on, but Snow had us looking in the wrong places.
Certainly, cultural gaps remain between the sciences and the humanities (although, in terms of scholarly literature, there is a remarkable degree of overlap and interchange, forming one big network with a number of fuzzy division). But C. P. Snow’s The Two Cultures seems less and less relevant for modern society; looking back, it even seems less relevant to its original context.
It’s been a while since I read Snow’s essay. I like your point about the people who now have the future in their bones, but you don’t mention one point that Snow emphasized: that someone who did not know the fundamental scientific facts he mentioned (Newton’s laws, the laws of thermodynamics) was ignorant — illiterate even — in the world of science, and that this was a problem unacknowledged as such by cultural academe. That doesn’t seem to me to have changed a great deal. Resolving it would not be a panacea for anything, of course.
Perhaps the reason that there is now more acceptance of the nature of the future among some cultural academics is precisely because it is easier to understand it — even literature professors surf the web and download music.
Thanks, Mike. In the paragraph beginning “Snow’s original idea”, that complaint is what I was trying to describe, that literary intellectuals didn’t understand science and didn’t care to.
But I think the fact that there still is such a thing as the humanities, separate from the sciences, obscures how different the place of science is today versus 1959. Actually, I think it’s tough to be considered a broadly learned scholar even in the humanities without a basic level of scientific literacy.
Certainly, the disdain that Snow describes is much rarer; the humanists who don’t know any science don’t flaunt it and aren’t proud of it, by and large.
Just as an anecdote: two people for me sort embody what it is to be a humanist savant in academia today, carrying on the tradition of the literary intellectual: Anthony Grafton and Jean-Cristophe Agnew. These are cultural historians (whose work has focused on the early modern period), and one wouldn’t expect them to be deeply knowledgeable about the modern sciences, and yet they are. I see that to a greater or lesser degree in much of the humanities; one can no longer make a serious argument that science is irrelevant for understanding culture.
Part of that, I think, has to do with the fact that there is hardly anyone left who was trained pre-Sputnik. Beginning in the 1960s, science became much more significant in high school, and also became more significant in liberal arts curricula in colleges. So since the 1960s, many more humanists have both rudimentary training in the sciences and many more opportunities to experience science-related cultural expressions.
You’re right, of course — you do mention that point. Perhaps I should have said that Snow seemed to me to make it more central to his argument than you make it. However, that’s moot, if, as you say, scientific literacy has really become more widespread since Snow’s day. I am still sceptical about the extent to which this has happened, but any movement in the right direction is a good thing.
Thanks for a thought-provoking post.
Mike, you’re right to sceptical here and I don’t want to overstate my point. Scientific illiteracy is still widespread (just as all kinds of specialist illiteracies exist even just within the humanities or within the sciences; this is the nature of the modern super-specialized academy), just somewhat less so (and somewhat more so for most kinds of humanist literacy).
But the class of people Snow was talking about, “literary intellectuals”, had already passed their peak of cultural significance in 1959, and the few who might merit that title today are a different breed.
https://drugsoverthecounter.shop/# over the counter yeast infection treatment
coursework plagiarism
do my coursework online
custom coursework writing
best sleep aid over the counter over the counter ed medication
https://over-the-counter-drug.com/# over the counter steroid cream
best over the counter dark spot remover bronchial inhalers over the counter
united healthcare over the counter essentials over the counter yeast infection treatment
clobetasol over the counter equivalent over the counter medicine for acid reflux
over the counter essentials epinephrine over the counter
over the counter anti inflammatory metronidazole over the counter
over the counter yeast infection treatment strongest over the counter painkillers
https://amoxil.science/# amoxicillin 1000 mg capsule
https://doxycycline.science/# where to purchase doxycycline
Drug information. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
ivermectin pill cost
Generic Name. Read information now.
Read now. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
stromectol in canada
Everything about medicine. Cautions.
What side effects can this medication cause? Top 100 Searched Drugs.
where to buy ivermectin
Get here. Get here.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. What side effects can this medication cause?
stromectol price
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Actual trends of drug. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
stromectol order online
Read information now. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
Read information now. Actual trends of drug.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin cost uk
Read information now. Everything information about medication.
Drugs information sheet. Get here.
ivermectin 18mg
safe and effective drugs are available. Best and news about drug.
Read information now. Long-Term Effects.
ivermectin syrup
Read information now. Get here.
Read information now. Drugs information sheet.
ivermectin generic cream
What side effects can this medication cause? Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Best and news about drug. Read information now.
ivermectin price canada
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Everything information about medication. Medicament prescribing information.
ivermectin 5
Actual trends of drug. Long-Term Effects.
Drug information. Drugs information sheet.
ivermectin 3mg tablets
Read information now. Get here.
Cautions. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
where to buy ivermectin
Everything what you want to know about pills. safe and effective drugs are available.
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 3mg
All trends of medicament. safe and effective drugs are available.
Read here. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
stromectol tablets uk
Get here. Get information now.
Long-Term Effects. Read information now.
https://nexium.top/# how can i get nexium without rx
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Everything information about medication.
What side effects can this medication cause? Read information now.
lisinopril 10 mg
Best and news about drug. Everything about medicine.
Everything information about medication. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
lisinopril 60 mg tablet
Everything about medicine. What side effects can this medication cause?
Read information now. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
https://mobic.store/# can i buy cheap mobic without insurance
Everything information about medication. Long-Term Effects.
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Everything information about medication. order generic avodart without rx
Read information now. Drug information.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Actual trends of drug.
lisinopril 40 mg tablet
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
All trends of medicament. Medicament prescribing information.
zestril pill
Best and news about drug. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
Get information now. drug information and news for professionals and consumers. can i buy avodart
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Everything information about medication.
can you buy generic levaquin pills
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
earch our drug database. Read here.
can you get generic nexium without rx
Actual trends of drug. earch our drug database.
Long-Term Effects. earch our drug database. https://avodart.science/# avodart pills
Get here. Drugs information sheet.
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Long-Term Effects. https://avodart.science/# order generic avodart no prescription
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. earch our drug database.
Cautions. Commonly Used Drugs Charts. amoxicillin 500mg cost
Drugs information sheet. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
Everything about medicine. All trends of medicament.
zithromax 500
Everything information about medication. safe and effective drugs are available.
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
https://clomiphenes.com generic clomid pills
Generic Name. Get information now.
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. earch our drug database. amoxicillin online canada
Read information now. Some trends of drugs.
Some trends of drugs. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
https://finasteridest.com/ cheap propecia tablets
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Get information now.
Get warning information here. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
where can i get propecia no prescription
earch our drug database. Get warning information here.
Drug information. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. amoxicillin from canada
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Drug information. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
cost clomid without rx
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
Long-Term Effects. Everything what you want to know about pills. https://amoxicillins.com/ amoxicillin without prescription
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
Read here. Get here.
can i purchase generic clomid without dr prescription
Everything about medicine. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
Read information now. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
where to buy cheap clomid without insurance
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Long-Term Effects.
Get here. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
https://azithromycins.online/ buy zithromax no prescription
Read now. Get here.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Cautions.
cheap zithromax pills
Read here. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
Generic Name. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
where can you buy zithromax
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Drugs information sheet. Long-Term Effects.
zithromax purchase online
safe and effective drugs are available. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Everything about medicine. https://amoxicillins.online/ cost of amoxicillin 875 mg
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Drugs information sheet. Everything about medicine.
where to get zithromax
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Actual trends of drug.
Generic Name. What side effects can this medication cause?
where can i get clomid without rx
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Read information now.
Drug information. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
https://edonlinefast.com pills for erection
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Actual trends of drug.
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
medications for ed
Actual trends of drug. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Actual trends of drug. Best and news about drug.
https://edonlinefast.com erectile dysfunction medicines
Read information now. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Some trends of drugs.
https://edonlinefast.com male ed drugs
Read information now. Read here.
Generic Name. What side effects can this medication cause?
https://edonlinefast.com otc ed pills
Everything what you want to know about pills. Generic Name.
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Everything what you want to know about pills.
https://edonlinefast.com best drug for ed
Read information now. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Actual trends of drug.
https://canadianfast.com/# buy prescription drugs from canada
earch our drug database. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
Cautions. Read information now.
https://canadianfast.com/# non prescription ed pills
Get warning information here. Everything about medicine.
Get warning information here. safe and effective drugs are available.
https://canadianfast.com/# amoxicillin without a doctor’s prescription
Everything information about medication. What side effects can this medication cause?
Get here. Everything about medicine.
escrow pharmacy canada
Generic Name. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Read now.
global pharmacy canada
Drug information. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Read here. Get warning information here.
canadian pharmacy cialis
Read here. Actual trends of drug.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Get information now.
vipps canadian pharmacy
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Get information now.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Best and news about drug.
https://canadianfast.online/# amoxicillin without a doctor’s prescription
Drugs information sheet. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Read here. Generic Name.
https://canadianfast.com/# prescription drugs online without doctor
Get here. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Best and news about drug. Drugs information sheet.
canadian drugs
earch our drug database. earch our drug database.
Get warning information here. safe and effective drugs are available.
canadian pharmacy review
safe and effective drugs are available. Everything what you want to know about pills.
safe and effective drugs are available. Read information now.
pharmacy wholesalers canada
Everything information about medication. Cautions.
Some trends of drugs. Generic Name.
safe canadian pharmacy
Best and news about drug. Generic Name.
Cautions. earch our drug database.
can i buy sildenafil citrate
Read information now. Read here.
Everything what you want to know about pills. safe and effective drugs are available.
how to order sildenafil online
Drug information. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
All trends of medicament. Read information now.
sildenafil 50 mg online us
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Get warning information here.
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. safe and effective drugs are available.
https://viagrapillsild.com/# sildenafil otc nz
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Best and news about drug.
Some trends of drugs. safe and effective drugs are available.
https://viagrapillsild.online/# 20 mg sildenafil 30 tablets cost
Get here. Long-Term Effects.
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Everything about medicine.
tadalafil best price
Drugs information sheet. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Everything information about medication.
cialis online safe
safe and effective drugs are available. Everything about medicine.
Ӏ have been checking out many of yߋur posts
and i must say nice stuff. I wilⅼ mаke
sure to bookmark yoսr website.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Get information now.
where can i buy tadalafil
Generic Name. Long-Term Effects.
Read here. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
price comparison tadalafil
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Everything information about medication.
safe and effective drugs are available. Read information now.
tadalafil 5mg canada
Get information now. Generic Name.
safe and effective drugs are available. Get warning information here.
review of cialis
safe and effective drugs are available. All trends of medicament.
Get here. Actual trends of drug.
drug categories viagra cialis
Get warning information here. Medicament prescribing information.
What side effects can this medication cause? Cautions.
tadalafil 20 mg over the counter
Some trends of drugs. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
Cautions. Generic Name.
cialis quebec dollars canadien
safe and effective drugs are available. Read information now.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
cialis from canadian pharmacy registerd
Read now. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
All trends of medicament. earch our drug database.
buy tadalafil 10mg india
Read now. What side effects can this medication cause?
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
https://tadalafil1st.com/# tadalafil mexico price
Everything about medicine. Long-Term Effects.
Get information now. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
where to get generic propecia for sale
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Drug information.
Some trends of drugs. All trends of medicament.
clomid order
Get here. Read information now.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
price for amoxicillin 875 mg
Everything what you want to know about pills. Drugs information sheet.