
I am writing wrote this on the plane back from my first Wikimania. Wow! An amazing experience!
First off, I couldn’t have written my ROFLCon blog post if I had been to Wikimania already. What is true of the social dynamic of Wikipedia meetups for (mainly) the English Wikipedia community–that we tend to be on the introverted side, and it takes a while for people to open up–doesn’t translate to the international scope and scale of Wikimania. Wikimedians there were warm and friendly from the get-go. Maybe it takes a critical mass of sociality before introverts start to open up, rather than merely time. So bigger is better.
Organizationally, things were modestly chaotic. For the most part this was fine. The one real fail was that many attendees were unexpectedly kicked out of their dorms early, and I heard that a group of them ended up spending one night in a public park.
It’s really a shame that Wikimania hasn’t been held in North America since Wikimania 2005 in Boston. That was before the real upswing of Wikipedia’s popularity, and the majority of active American and Canadian Wikimedians have never had a chance since they joined to attend a nearby Wikimania.

One of the highlights of the conference was the premiere of Truth in Numbers?, a documentary about Wikipedia that’s been about 5 years in the making. It’ll be released publicly later this year. Reactions from Wikipedians were mixed and complicated, although during the screening itself it felt like a very positive reaction. The film gives a lot of focus to some shallow or misleading lines of criticism, and on an intellectual level, it comes off as largely anti-Wikipedia, contrasting the reasonable-sounding arguments of mature critics with the naive optimism of youthful Wikipedians. (For the most part, the critics’ arguments are easily answered, but the counter-arguments are a little more sophisticated than what can be explained well in a documentary aimed at an audience with little Wikipedia background.) Emotionally, though, I felt that Wikipedia–or rather, the Wikipedians–win in a landslide.
The Truth in Numbers? filmmakers also plan on releasing all the used and unused footage–full interviews with Wikipedians from around the world as well as important critics and supporters–so that others can re-edit and re-purpose it. There are many stories that could have been told in Truth in Numbers? I think the film is emotionally satisfying and it’s strong by the standards of the documentary genre. Comparing it with other documentaries about weird communities, it’s far better than, say, Revolution OS, but not quite to the level Darkon or Spellbound. I’m excited to see what else might come of it. A film intended to tell the history of Wikipedia would be quite different, and a film about the politics and values and philosophy of the Wikimedia movement would be different yet again. Hopefully the licensing of the extra footage will be free enough that the Wikimedia community can actually use it.
It was so great meeting many of the people I’ve known only online. Really, Wikimedians are the awesome-est people in the world. A whole year is too long until Wikimania 2011 in Haifa, Israel. Hopefully I’ll be able to make it to Wiki-Conference New York in August to hold me over; last year’s was great, and this year’s should be even better.

I took a few pictures, which seem to have been well received. They’re all on Wikimedia Commons, too, along with 1000 others. As a default, I didn’t add names for anyone but Wikimedia board and staff, since many Wikimedians may not like having named pics publicly available. But let me know and I’ll add your name to your pic, if you like.
Sage, I think one of the main reasons why there hasn’t been a North American Wikimania in so long is that the Foundation is deathly afraid that I’ll show up.
ORLY?
Well, it’s either that or the fact that Jimbo and Sue and Erik want the ability to travel to fun, new, and exotic places, all on the Foundation’s dime. What fun would it be for them schlepping their bags off to Kansas City?
You say “The film gives a lot of focus to some shallow or misleading lines of criticism, and on an intellectual level, it comes off as largely anti-Wikipedia, contrasting the reasonable-sounding arguments of mature critics with the naive optimism of youthful Wikipedians. ”
Are you saying that the shallow or misleading criticism is the same as the “reasonable-sounding arguments of mature critics”.
Can you say what you think the critics’ arguments are? What are the sophisticated counter-arguments? My criticism of Wikipedia is that while it handles the exact sciences pretty well, it is a mess when it comes to the humanities subjects (I am a humanities PhD). It also gives undue weight to popular subjects as opposed to more, er, encyclopedic ones.
The chief critic is Andrew Keen, if that gives you an idea of the intellectual tenor. Probably there’s nothing in the film that isn’t discussed in more detail in [[Criticism of Wikipedia]].
By reasonable-sounding, I mean reasonable in tone and made by respectable-looking people. For example, I was really surprised to see Cade Metz on screen; he pulls off the “hard-boiled reporter” look perfectly, and you’d never know that his stock-in-trade for covering Wikipedia is tabloid half-truths and rumors just from watching those clips.
You are, of course, right that the humanities are a great challenge for Wikipedia. And as for popular subjects, yes, they get much more attention on Wikipedia by virtue of being popular. Neither of those things mean (as people like Keen argue) that amateurs are simply unsuitable encyclopedia contributors or that Wikipedia is worthless or on-the-whole harmful.
When rumors turn out to be true (can you point to a single Cade Metz “rumor” that has ultimately proved false?), that’s simply good reporting, Sage. You are finding difficult to critique your employer, and that’s to be understood. However, casting undocumented aspersions at a journalist like Metz is rather unbecoming. Please, do point to one of Metz’ “rumor” items that has turned out to be unfounded.
I think we’ve reached the point in this conversation where we have irreconcilable viewpoints. From my perspective, pretty much everything Metz has written about Wikipedia represents a wildly distorted view of reality.
It may be that Cade Metz reports only on the dark underbelly of Wikipedia, which I agree is a bias in his writing. But, it’s not that anything he has ever reported on has been a “half-truth” or a “rumor”, as you’ve characterized it here. Your readers deserve to judge for themselves, even if you are strangely bent on defaming Metz’ reputation as a journalist, regardless of the facts as shown before you:
http://tinyurl.com/Cade-Metz-Wikipedia
Certainly, people should judge for themselves. The same is true for the film, of course.
By the way, the website I initially linked was not the official one, it looks like. There are already some full interviews up, and more are supposed to be released gradually, at http://truthinnumbersthemovie.com/
You haven’t answered his objection. Everything I have read by Cade seems like whole truth to me. I have been interviewed by him and he is quite scrupulous.
>>You are, of course, right that the humanities are a great challenge for Wikipedia.
Thank you, though I think ‘mess’ is more accurate than ‘challenge’.
>>The chief critic is Andrew Keen, if that gives you an idea of the intellectual tenor.
I saw other names on the trailer – Susan Jacoby, Chomsky – these are weighty names.
I know little of Keen’s work, though I shall order ‘Cult of the Amateur’.
>>And as for popular subjects, yes, they get much more attention on Wikipedia by virtue of being popular.
That’s rather damning. Popular subjects are those which everyone knows about. If you are searching for knowledge, it’s the subjects that people know little about which are important. It’s rather like having an encyclopedia that is meant to be about exciting and exotic places, but in fact all the contributors are from Surbiton, so all the articles are about Surbiton (US readers: ‘Bakersville’ or ‘Minneapolis’).
>>Neither of those things mean (as people like Keen argue) that amateurs are simply unsuitable encyclopedia contributors
Well ‘amateur’ means ‘lover’, but if you mean ‘non expert’, as I suspect he does’, then he is absolutely right. When it comes to my specialist subject, it is very poorly represented on Wikipedia. People how know nothing about my subject are definitely unsuitable as contributors. I don’t mind if they don’t contribute. However when they insist upon including their strange and eccentric opinions I find it very tiresome (this is the main reason I am banned – I have very little patience with these types).
Yes, Wikipedia isn’t the place for people who are unwilling to suffer fools. That’s not a good thing, per se, but it’s also the only way the world gets any better: when people who aren’t fools engage with people who are, and try to help them find that bit of enlightenment. That Wikipedia recapitulates so many of the failings of the broader culture is also the reason why Wikipedia is such a great opportunity to work toward a better culture.
The world can also get better when the fools pay for tuition of some sort and are awarded a degree if they are capable enough. Then the teacher gets paid. Sorry, I like teaching but I prefer to get paid for it. Actually I would do it for free if it were not so painful. But it is. Contributing to Wikipedia is like paying good money for giving your knowledge away.
On ‘failing the broader culture’, well, universities have existed since the Middle Ages and they are still the best place to get a good education. Forget Wikipedia, please.
Well, ragesoss, aren’t you a little bit too focused on Americans. I had an impression that Wikimedia is a global endeavour.
Wikimedia being a global endeavour doesn’t preclude holding Wikimania in North America every so often. Wikimania is for the editors, and a large portion of editors are from the U.S. and Canada. Most of them have never gotten a chance to attend a Wikimania, because they’ve all been very far away since 2005.
I have some further comments here
http://ocham.blogspot.com/2010/07/cult-of-amateur-lessig-vs-keen.html
And Cade Metz comments on this blog here
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/07/16/cade_wikipedia/
Thanks, Peter. That’s not Cade Metz, that’s another Reg writer, Lester Haines.
And a very good writer he is too!
Note: this post and its comments are the subject of an article in The Register, “Reg hack gives forth in Wikipedia doco“.
To re-iterate in case it wasn’t clear, I think Truth in Numbers? gives a quite positive view of Wikipedia overall, in spite of fairly uncritical treatment of some of the basic arguments made by Wikipedia critics. I really hope the film does well and is seen widely, and I think a lot of other Wikipedians felt the same way.
The main criticisms are
1. That a list of facts is not the same as a fact.
2. That by some magic having anyone able to edit something makes it somehow better.
3. That people in real life can get hurt by Wikipedia.
Answers to these criticisms please!
There is some validity to each of these points, of course, but you’re not raising any issues Wikipedians haven’t debated to death many times before.
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Why_Wikipedia_is_not_so_great
In spite of all that, Wikipedia’s virtues far outweigh its faults, in my view. You disagree, and that’s fine.
>>Wikipedia’s virtues far outweigh its faults, in my view
But please give arguments. The page you linked to, where you say ‘Wikipedians have debated to death’ these issues, does not discuss any of the points I have been raising. Specifically, Wikipedia is a mass of trivia. The exact sciences are pretty good, I agree. The ‘soft sciences’, particularly the humanities, are a complete wreck. How do you get from ‘complete wreck’ to ‘virtues outweigh faults’? Have you looked at some of the articles I have been talking about, here and in my blog?
Sorry to bang on about this.
Peter, I’m not interested in having this argument. It was interesting to me 4 years ago when I started, but all the points you raise are minor variations on common lines of criticism.
Wikipedia has problems, and I (along with a lot of other Wikipedians) am interested in fixing or ameliorating them. But debating with people who want to see the whole project fail or view it as a hopeless endeavor is a waste of time.
A further post here
http://ocham.blogspot.com/2010/07/truth-in-numbers.html
A lot of Wikipedians argue that the truth will somehow come out of the principle that ‘anyone can edit’. Why? Common sense and logic suggests that mostly lies will come out of this principle. Furthermore, examination of Wikipedia itself seems to prove this. Comments please!
“It is a piece of idle sentimentality that truth, merely as truth, has any inherent power denied to error”. John Stuart Mill
https://drugsoverthecounter.shop/# the best over counter sleep aid
zofran over the counter over the counter cough medicine
over the counter asthma inhaler corticosteroids over the counter
ringworm treatment over the counter male uti treatment over the counter
https://over-the-counter-drug.com/# nausea medicine over the counter for pregnancy
over the counter sleep aid cvs over the counter asthma inhaler
anti nausea medication over the counter best over the counter teeth whitening
over the counter sleeping pills over the counter heartburn medicine
over the counter essentials login uti medicine over the counter
over the counter drugs over the counter uti meds
https://stromectol.science/# buy ivermectin uk
https://stromectol.science/# buy ivermectin for humans uk
https://amoxil.science/# order amoxicillin uk
Drugs information sheet. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin for humans
Read here. earch our drug database.
Get here. Get here.
https://stromectolst.com/# stromectol price in india
Read here. Read information now.
Some trends of drugs. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
purchase oral ivermectin
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Read information now.
Get information now. What side effects can this medication cause?
ivermectin oral solution
Generic Name. Read here.
Best and news about drug. Drugs information sheet.
stromectol covid 19
Best and news about drug. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. safe and effective drugs are available.
ivermectin cost uk
Get here. What side effects can this medication cause?
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
stromectol buy uk
Everything information about medication. earch our drug database.
Everything about medicine. What side effects can this medication cause?
generic ivermectin for humans
Actual trends of drug. What side effects can this medication cause?
Get here. Everything what you want to know about pills.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 500mg
Cautions. Read here.
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Read information now.
ivermectin 80 mg
Some trends of drugs. Read information now.
Long-Term Effects. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
п»їorder stromectol online
Long-Term Effects. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
All trends of medicament. Read information now.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin where to buy
Everything information about medication. safe and effective drugs are available.
Medicament prescribing information. Get here.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin cream 5%
safe and effective drugs are available. Long-Term Effects.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Best and news about drug.
ivermectin rx
Read here. Read information now.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Get information now.
stromectol 3 mg tablets price
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Drug information. Read information now.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin australia
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Get warning information here.
Some trends of drugs. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
stromectol 3 mg
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
earch our drug database. Best and news about drug.
cost generic nexium no prescription
Read information now. Actual trends of drug.
All trends of medicament. earch our drug database.
https://mobic.store/# get generic mobic without a prescription
Long-Term Effects. Get information now.
Everything information about medication. Actual trends of drug. can i get cheap avodart without dr prescription
Drug information. Read now.
Drug information. Drug information.
can i purchase cheap mobic online
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Everything about medicine.
Long-Term Effects. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
buy levaquin pill
Read now. Long-Term Effects.
Get warning information here. Everything information about medication.
https://nexium.top/# where buy nexium without rx
Cautions. Long-Term Effects.
Actual trends of drug. Read information now.
can i purchase nexium for sale
Everything about medicine. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Long-Term Effects. Get information now.
buy cheap levaquin no prescription
Read information now. Drugs information sheet.
Drugs information sheet. All trends of medicament. https://avodart.science/# avodart online
Long-Term Effects. Best and news about drug.
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Medscape Drugs & Diseases. can you buy cheap avodart online
Get warning information here. Long-Term Effects.
Everything about medicine. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
how can i get generic levaquin without dr prescription
Read information now. Actual trends of drug.
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Everything about medicine.
https://mobic.store/# where buy generic mobic without insurance
Generic Name. earch our drug database.
Everything about medicine. Get information now.
how to get generic nexium tablets
Drugs information sheet. Cautions.
Read here. Get information now. buy amoxicillin online mexico
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Drug information.
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Cautions. https://amoxicillins.com/ medicine amoxicillin 500mg
All trends of medicament. Drugs information sheet.
Actual trends of drug. Read information now.
buy generic zithromax no prescription
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Get information now.
safe and effective drugs are available. What side effects can this medication cause?
can i order clomid pill
Everything information about medication. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Get warning information here. Read now.
how to buy generic propecia price
safe and effective drugs are available. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
https://clomiphenes.online how to buy clomid for sale
Long-Term Effects. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
Drugs information sheet. Drug information.
https://clomiphenes.com can you get generic clomid without dr prescription
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
Everything information about medication. Generic Name.
can you buy zithromax over the counter
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Read information now.
What side effects can this medication cause? Everything what you want to know about pills.
how to get propecia for sale
Everything about medicine. Drugs information sheet.
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Everything what you want to know about pills.
cost of cheap clomid tablets
What side effects can this medication cause? Cautions.
Get warning information here. Long-Term Effects. amoxicillin 500mg capsules
Read information now. Get here.
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Read here.
can i get clomid without insurance
Actual trends of drug. safe and effective drugs are available.
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Medscape Drugs & Diseases. can i buy amoxicillin online
Some trends of drugs. Best and news about drug.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Everything information about medication.
where to buy generic clomid online
Cautions. earch our drug database.
earch our drug database. Everything information about medication.
https://clomiphenes.online where buy generic clomid pill
Read here. Some trends of drugs.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
generic propecia no prescription
Read information now. earch our drug database.
Long-Term Effects. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
https://finasteridest.online cost of cheap propecia tablets
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Drugs information sheet.
Everything about medicine. Read here.
non prescription ed drugs
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. safe and effective drugs are available.
Get warning information here. What side effects can this medication cause?
ed meds
Generic Name. safe and effective drugs are available.
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Best and news about drug.
men’s ed pills
Everything information about medication. Long-Term Effects.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
https://edonlinefast.com cures for ed
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
earch our drug database. Some trends of drugs.
where to get cheap clomid for sale
What side effects can this medication cause? safe and effective drugs are available.
Drug information. Get here.
erectile dysfunction medicines
Read information now. Everything what you want to know about pills.
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Cautions.
ed meds online without doctor prescription
Cautions. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
Drugs information sheet. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
ed medication online
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
What side effects can this medication cause? Best and news about drug.
https://edonlinefast.com ed pill
п»їMedicament prescribing information. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
Medicament prescribing information. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
ed meds online without doctor prescription
Everything what you want to know about pills. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
Generic Name. Get information now.
pet antibiotics without vet prescription
Generic Name. Everything what you want to know about pills.
earch our drug database. Everything about medicine.
prescription drugs without doctor approval
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Get here.
Drug information. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
best canadian pharmacy for viagra
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. What side effects can this medication cause?
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Generic Name.
best canadian online pharmacy
Drug information. Read information now.
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
https://canadianfast.com/# prescription drugs without doctor approval
Read here. Long-Term Effects.
Best and news about drug. Drugs information sheet.
canadian pharmacy 365
Best and news about drug. Read information now.
earch our drug database. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
canadian pharmacy viagra reviews
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Generic Name.
Actual trends of drug. Actual trends of drug.
https://canadianfast.com/# buy cheap prescription drugs online
What side effects can this medication cause? Cautions.
Generic Name. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
pharmacy canadian
Everything information about medication. Drug information.
Cautions. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
amoxicillin without a doctor’s prescription
Best and news about drug. Everything about medicine.
Long-Term Effects. Generic Name.
trustworthy canadian pharmacy
Actual trends of drug. safe and effective drugs are available.
Generic Name. Read information now.
canadian medications
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Cautions.
earch our drug database. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
comfortis for dogs without vet prescription
Long-Term Effects. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
Read information now. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
viagra single tabs
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Everything information about medication.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Actual trends of drug.
try viagra for free
What side effects can this medication cause? Cautions.
Read information now. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
https://viagrapillsild.com/# how much viagra required australia
Read information now. safe and effective drugs are available.
Get warning information here. Everything information about medication.
sildenafil canada prescription
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Some trends of drugs.
Read now. Everything about medicine.
best price for generic sildenafil
Some trends of drugs. Best and news about drug.
Some trends of drugs. Generic Name.
https://viagrapillsild.online/# viagra brand
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Get warning information here.
Read information now. What side effects can this medication cause?
tadalafil soft gel capsule 20mg
Get warning information here. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
Actual trends of drug. Read information now.
tadalafil 10 mg canadian pharmacy
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Get here.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Generic Name.
tadalafil 10mg generic
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Read information now.
What side effects can this medication cause? Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
buy cialis online in austalia
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. safe and effective drugs are available.
Best and news about drug. Read information now.
https://tadalafil1st.com/# where to buy cialis in australia
Medicament prescribing information. Read here.
Long-Term Effects. Read here.
buy tadalafil 20mg uk
Read here. What side effects can this medication cause?
All trends of medicament. Everything information about medication.
tadalafil best price
Actual trends of drug. What side effects can this medication cause?
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Best and news about drug.
dapoxetine cialis
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Best and news about drug.
Actual trends of drug. Everything information about medication.
https://tadalafil1st.com/# tadalafil 22 mg
Drugs information sheet. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
Read information now. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
https://tadalafil1st.com/# cialis daily
Drug information. Generic Name.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
buy cialis using paypal
Read here. Some trends of drugs.
Best and news about drug. Get warning information here.
where can i get cheap clomid pills
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Long-Term Effects.
All trends of medicament. Cautions.
zithromax 250 mg tablet price
Cautions. Drugs information sheet.
What side effects can this medication cause? Some trends of drugs.
https://zithromaxa.fun/ buy zithromax online cheap
earch our drug database. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Please visit this website for a sec “부산펀초이스” to see my my pics and for avail for more sexy vids 😉 😉 ,
homeopathic remedies for ed: ed causes and treatment – ed meds online
how can i order prescription drugs without a doctor ed treatment options treatment of ed