Britannica Blog’s Web 2.0 forum is wrapping up this week. On the Wikipedia front, Michael Gorman has delivered his promised Wikipedia post, and danah boyd has an exceptional reply on why Wikipedia, and access to knowledge in general, is important. While Gorman’s posts are consistently vapid and unprovocative (except in the sense that cable news talking points are provocative), some of the other new media critics–particularly Seth Finkelstein–highlight an important issue that I think is at the heart of the debate. Namely, how do Wikipedia and other aspects of the read/write web knowledge ecosystem affect experts/professionals and their traditional systems of knowledge production?
The shared assumption amongst critics is that the effects are largely negative. Finkelstein put it dramatically in a comment directed at boyd. He characterizes the ‘experts should stop complaining about Wikipedia’s problems and just fix them’ refrain as “arguing that “capitalists” should give – not even sell, but give – Wikipedia the rope to hang them with!” He adds, “If an expert writes a good Wikipedia article, that gets claimed as the wisdom of crowds and presented as proof that amateurs can do just as well as experts.” So scholars are putting themselves out of a job by contributing to Wikipedia and the like.
Setting aside the ‘Wikipedia=Wisdom of Crowds’ strawman that so many Wikipedia critics knock down as their first and final argument, Finkelstein (and some of the others) hit on an important argument: amateur-produced knowledge products (often of inferior quality) are free, and this endangers the (political, financial, intellectual, and/or cultural) economies of expertise. But is that true? Is Wikipedia reducing the demand for scholarly monographs? Is writing a good Wikipedia article on the history of biology going to cut into the sales of all the sources I cite? Is it going to fill the demand for history of biology scholarship and make it tougher to find a publisher for my own work? In economic terms, the competition argument against Wikipedia assumes that traditionally-produced expert knowledge and community-produced knowledge are substitute goods with respect to each other (and are not substitute goods with respect to even lower quality knowledge products like cable news, tabloids, and CNN.com), that either demand for knowledge is relatively static or increased consumption isn’t necessarily desirable, and that knowledge products do not have significant prestige value linked to their traditional pricey modes of production (i.e., they aren’t Veblen goods).
Which of these assumptions holds true differs according to what genre of knowledge we’re talking about. Wikipedia is obviously a substitute for traditional encyclopedias (even if inferior); the Wikipedia threat has been obvious to Britannica and her since 2003. And while consumption of encyclopedia-style knowledge has increased tremendously, critics can argue that the quality is so inferior that it isn’t worth the displacement of traditional encyclopedia consumption. Britannica is also realizing that the mystique of their brand isn’t what it used to be; raising prices in certainly not going to increase demand. So for the encyclopedia genre, Wikipedia is harmful to the traditional expert production system, and possibly (depending on the quality level) harmful to society as a whole.
For original expert research, the stuff of scholarly books and journal articles, the situation is very different. In some cases, Wikipedia articles might act as subsitute goods for scholarly books and journals. However, an encyclopedia article is a fundamentally different knowledge product from an original journal article. The typical journal article is far deeper, and far less accessible, than the approximately corresponding Wikipedia article. My feeling is that rather than act as substitutes, Wikipedia articles and expert research usually contribute to network effects: a good Wikipedia article draws in new knowledge consumers, some of whom then delve into the expert research. In the world of the ivory tower, a humanist scholar usually has to worry much more about competition from the countless other topics out there than about an oversupply of work on one’s own topic. The more people hear about your topic, the more demand there is for your expertise.
News is the other main genre to consider. The newspaper industry has been in a downward spiral for years. Television news is a powerful competitor, and it’s plausible (though by no means obvious) that Wikipedia, citizen journalism, and the blogosphere are contributing to the slow death of the newspapers as well. (Sadly, it’s not plausible that Wikinews is contributing to the downfall of print journalism. At some point, the disintegration of professional journalism may reach a critical mass, and citizen journalism will step up to fill the holes left by the shrinking New York Times. Wikinews has the potential to become the most important media organization in the world, but at this point it still has virtually no impact beyond the Wikimedia community.)
But it seems that the shift to the web (with its drastically lower ad revenues) and the competition among newspapers that can now compete across the country (or even globally) is the main cause. Papers used to have more-or-less local monopolies for print news; they would buy national and world news from the wire agencies (for which they were the only local suppliers) and pour most of their revenue into local and regional reporting. But now, any paper can use the internet to hock national and international news, and consumption of that kind of knowledge product is fairly static (at least compared to encyclopedia article consumption). So competition lowers the price of broad news (with modest increases in text-based news consumption, at best) and restricts the production (and increases the price) of local and investigative journalism.
The situation is much the same as the late-19th/early-20th century steel and railroad industries: there is just to much competition for a stable marketplace, so we’re seeing mergers and increasingly powerful media conglomerates (and the government is more willing to sign off on cross-media mergers). So I don’t think that web 2.0 knowledge products are responsible for the troubles of professional journalism, but if they don’t step up to fill the gaps, maybe nothing will.
Roger Kimball (cultural critic and c0-editor of the conservative literary magazine The New Criterion) has a sharp take on the dangers of cyberspace (hint: they have nothing to do with threats to traditional expertise and everything to do with the real world we’re missing as we piddle around in virtual worlds). Kimball’s points are worth keeping in mind, and on the topic of journalism and web 2.0, one of the key ways to avoid some of the dangers of cyberspace is to create and participate in online communities that are focused on the real world (e.g., Wikinews and the parts of Wikipedia that are not about entertainment).
(P.S.: I don’t actually know anything about economics, so treat my analysis like you would a Wikipedia article)
Bonus links:
- “What Wikipedia can teach us about the new media literacies”, part 1 and part 2, by Henry Jenkins
- “Viewing American class divisions through Facebook and MySpace“, by danah boyd
nice blog
http://xkcd.com/c285.html
wikipedian protestor
On the internet-related woes of the news industry, see Russell Baker’s recent “Goodbye to Newspapers?” from the NY Review of Books.
Linked via Lead and Gold, where Craig Henry offers interpretations that are distinctly at odds with Baker’s.
—-
On changing patterns of knowledge ‘consumption’: Wikipedia has scratched my itch regarding a plethora of topics, from banal to crucial. I’m reasonably confident that an article will provide the lay of the land, and it often serves as the final word on trivial matters (how much more do I need to know about the Cylons?)
But since I never know the biases and blind spots of the authors, I never trust Wikipedia on any question of interpretation on any issue of substance. In those cases, it is an early stop in a broader search.
How common is this approach? I suspect it’s not rare among those prone to skepticism.
AMac, thanks for the link. Craig Henry has a very provocative interpretation; as is hopefully clear from my post, my views don’t quite line up with Baker or Henry. I think Henry’s idea that newspapers have been sinking their excess profit into low-value-added content isn’t the right picture of what’s happening. The question is, as they feel financial crunch, are they going to cut sports analysis, opinion and trendspotting, or local hard news and investigative journalism? I think probably the latter; the competition is forcing them to focus on the kinds of things that will get them the most readers instead of choosing what they think people need to know about. On the surface, from any sort of (classical, neo-, or modern American) liberal perspective, that seems like a good thing. But it amounts to letting your kid choose ice cream for dinner every night. Wider margins, if not monopolies, gave newspaper editors more control
over readers’ news diets; competition and tight margins means catering to the a priori news preferences of the broadest market segment possible…who don’t know nearly as much about what their news choices are pushing out as the editors do.
It seems like the fundamental problem is the differential between print and internet advertising; if online newspapers can’t make more than a fraction of the ad revenue online as they could in print, even with the same level of readership, then there are going to be problems.
Re: Wikipedia
I think the pattern of Wikipedia use that you use is pretty common, among those who are prone to skepticism.
More importantly, I think Wikipedia’s widespread use among people who aren’t normally skeptical (enough) of what they read is fostering more skepticism about published material in general.
After all, Wikipedia (transparently unreliable medium that it is) often points out flaws and errors that mainstream media and traditional popular sources overlook. And Wikipedia’s reputation for (un)reliability is actually worse than reality, unlike traditional sources that have a much better reputation than they deserve. So I see Wikipedia as having very little downside in terms of media literacy
It should be relatively easy to find these blocks, even if you re thinking about it at year 4 and want to do the test and then have an informed decision with your patient by giving them this extra tool, which is very valuable on top of the clinical features and patient preference to make that decision buy cialis online with a prescription
hello there and thank you for your information – I’ve definitely picked up something new from right here.I did however expertise some technical issues using this web site, as I experienced to reload the site many times previous toI could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if yourweb host is OK? Not that I’m complaining, but slow loading instancestimes will sometimes affect your placement in google and could damage your high-qualityscore if ads and marketing with Adwords. Anyway Iam adding this RSS to my email and could look out for a lot more of your respective interesting content.Make sure you update this again soon.
https://drugsoverthecounter.shop/# muscle relaxer over the counter
naproxen 500mg over the counter over the counter nausea medicine
https://over-the-counter-drug.com/# over the counter sleeping pills
ラブドール販売 等身大のダッチワイフは理想的なセックスパートナーですか?女性は本当に男性のダッチワイフをねじ込むのが好きですか?あなたはダッチワイフにいくら使うことができますか?チャイルドセックス人形クリエーター:それは公共サービスです
tamiflu over the counter mupirocin ointment over the counter
over the counter allergy medicine epinephrine over the counter
https://over-the-counter-drug.com/# over the counter laxatives
over the counter pain medication over the counter muscle relaxers
bv treatment over the counter over the counter antihistamine
silvadene cream over the counter over the counter pain meds
best over the counter hair color wellcare over the counter ordering
https://zithromax.science/# zithromax 600 mg tablets
Get information now. Long-Term Effects.
stromectol ivermectin buy
Everything what you want to know about pills. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
What side effects can this medication cause? safe and effective drugs are available.
ivermectin 4
Everything information about medication. Read now.
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
ivermectin 50
All trends of medicament. Everything about medicine.
Everything information about medication. earch our drug database.
https://stromectolst.com/# stromectol tab 3mg
Read here. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Everything what you want to know about pills.
ivermectin cream uk
Read now. Actual trends of drug.
Best and news about drug. Best and news about drug.
oral ivermectin cost
Cautions. Get information now.
Generic Name. Drugs information sheet.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin cost
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
Best and news about drug. earch our drug database.
stromectol over the counter
Actual trends of drug. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
Drugs information sheet. All trends of medicament.
ivermectin 6 mg tablets
What side effects can this medication cause? Cautions.
All trends of medicament. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
buy ivermectin uk
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Commonly Used Drugs Charts.
Get warning information here. Get information now.
stromectol online canada
Some trends of drugs. Some trends of drugs.
Read information now. Read here.
ivermectin 400 mg brands
Actual trends of drug. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
Best and news about drug. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
buy ivermectin cream
Get warning information here. Medicament prescribing information.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
ivermectin for humans
Generic Name. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. earch our drug database.
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 12
Cautions. Get here.
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
stromectol price in india
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Read information now.
What side effects can this medication cause? Drug information.
ivermectin 1mg
Drugs information sheet. Get information now.
Get here. Long-Term Effects.
https://mobic.store/# how to get mobic
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Drugs information sheet.
All trends of medicament. Some trends of drugs.
lisinopril price 10 mg
Best and news about drug. Get warning information here.
What side effects can this medication cause? Everything what you want to know about pills.
cost mobic without rx
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Read here. avodart pill
Some trends of drugs. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
Get here. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
buying generic nexium pills
safe and effective drugs are available. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Medicament prescribing information. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
https://levaquin.science/# can i get cheap levaquin without rx
Everything about medicine. Get information now.
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Read information now.
where can i get cheap levaquin for sale
Generic Name. Read here.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
get generic mobic no prescription
Drugs information sheet. Read here.
Medicament prescribing information. Actual trends of drug.
can i order cheap levaquin without rx
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Medicament prescribing information.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
how can i get cheap levaquin without insurance
Some trends of drugs. Get information now.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Top 100 Searched Drugs. https://avodart.science/# can i get cheap avodart prices
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Actual trends of drug.
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Everything about medicine.
https://mobic.store/# can you get generic mobic without rx
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
All trends of medicament. Best and news about drug.
https://finasteridest.com/ where buy propecia without insurance
Everything about medicine. earch our drug database.
Read information now. Everything what you want to know about pills.
cost generic clomid
Long-Term Effects. Read information now.
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Everything about medicine.
п»їclomid
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Cautions.
Actual trends of drug. Get here.
https://clomiphenes.com where can i buy clomid without a prescription
All trends of medicament. Read here.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Actual trends of drug.
can you get cheap propecia without rx
Get warning information here. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
Actual trends of drug. Get here. how much is amoxicillin
earch our drug database. Read information now.
Get warning information here. Cautions.
zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online
Read now. Best and news about drug.
Best and news about drug. earch our drug database.
generic propecia without prescription
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Read now.
Cautions. Top 100 Searched Drugs. https://amoxicillins.com/ buy amoxicillin over the counter uk
Read information now. Generic Name.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Get warning information here.
zithromax online pharmacy canada
Best and news about drug. earch our drug database.
Everything information about medication. Generic Name.
can i buy cheap propecia without rx
Cautions. Read information now.
earch our drug database. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
where can i buy generic propecia now
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. What side effects can this medication cause?
Drug information. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. amoxicillin 500 mg for sale
Generic Name. Read information now.
Long-Term Effects. earch our drug database.
https://clomiphenes.com how to get generic clomid without a prescription
Generic Name. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Best and news about drug.
https://clomiphenes.com get cheap clomid online
Generic Name. What side effects can this medication cause?
All trends of medicament. Read now.
where buy cheap clomid no prescription
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Read now.
Best and news about drug. Drug information.
https://edonlinefast.com top ed pills
Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe. Everything what you want to know about pills.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. Read here.
treatments for ed
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. safe and effective drugs are available.
Medscape Drugs & Diseases. Best and news about drug.
ed pills online
Generic Name. What side effects can this medication cause?
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Some trends of drugs.
best ed medication
safe and effective drugs are available. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
ed drug prices
Everything what you want to know about pills. All trends of medicament.
Cautions. safe and effective drugs are available.
ed pills gnc
Actual trends of drug. Everything about medicine.
Read here. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
https://edonlinefast.com non prescription erection pills
Everything information about medication. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Long-Term Effects. safe and effective drugs are available. https://amoxicillins.com/ purchase amoxicillin online
Everything what you want to know about pills. Drug information.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
https://edonlinefast.com cheap ed pills
Get warning information here. Drugs information sheet.
Get information now. Medicament prescribing information.
п»їed drugs online from canada
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. Get information now.
Drugs information sheet. Everything information about medication.
https://canadianfast.online/# canadian online drugstore
Get information now. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Read information now.
buy canadian drugs
All trends of medicament. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Cautions.
canadian discount pharmacy
Generic Name. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
Drugs information sheet. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
canadian pharmacy online
Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information. What side effects can this medication cause?
Everything about medicine. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
https://canadianfast.com/# how to get prescription drugs without doctor
earch our drug database. Get information now.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. safe and effective drugs are available.
how to get prescription drugs without doctor
Long-Term Effects. Get here.
Get information now. earch our drug database.
https://canadianfast.com/# best ed pills non prescription
All trends of medicament. Everything about medicine.
earch our drug database. Some are medicines that help people when doctors prescribe.
https://canadianfast.online/# pain medications without a prescription
Get warning information here. Generic Name.
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Some trends of drugs.
canadian drug
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Read information now.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
https://canadianfast.com/# pet antibiotics without vet prescription
Drug information. earch our drug database.
Top 100 Searched Drugs. safe and effective drugs are available.
prescription drugs online without doctor
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Get here.
Long-Term Effects. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
best online canadian pharmacy
Read now. Cautions.
Everything what you want to know about pills. Read now.
buy prescription drugs from canada
safe and effective drugs are available. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Everything what you want to know about pills.
https://canadianfast.online/# canadian medications
Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side. Everything information about medication.
Long-Term Effects. Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
https://viagrapillsild.online/# viagra substitute food
Some trends of drugs. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
It’s in point of fact a great and useful piece of info.
I am happy that you shared this helpful info with us.
Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for
sharing.
Get information now. Actual trends of drug.
viagra with overnight shipping
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Best and news about drug.
Commonly Used Drugs Charts. All trends of medicament.
viagra from doctors in melbourne
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Everything information about medication.
Best and news about drug. Best and news about drug.
https://viagrapillsild.com/# viagra via paypal
Read now. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Get information now. Everything information about medication.
buy sildenafil mexico
Some trends of drugs. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Drug information. Read information now.
does walmart sell viagra?
Actual trends of drug. Generic Name.
Generic Name. All trends of medicament.
ordering viagra online is it legal
Actual trends of drug. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
safe and effective drugs are available. Get here.
https://tadalafil1st.online/# can you buy cialis with no prescription
All trends of medicament. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Best and news about drug. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
cialis no perscription overnight delivery
Some trends of drugs. safe and effective drugs are available.
drug information and news for professionals and consumers. Generic Name.
generic cialis?
Read information now. Drug information.
earch our drug database. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
purchase cialis online
Some trends of drugs. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
Actual trends of drug. Drug information.
https://tadalafil1st.com/# cialis for sale
earch our drug database. Comprehensive side effect and adverse reaction information.
Get here. Get here.
google south africa cialis
Best and news about drug. Top 100 Searched Drugs.
Top 100 Searched Drugs. Some trends of drugs.
https://tadalafil1st.com/# best prices on cialis online
п»їMedicament prescribing information. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Read here. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
https://tadalafil1st.online/# cialis for sell
Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions. earch our drug database.
Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics. Some trends of drugs.
tadalafil 2.5 mg price
safe and effective drugs are available. Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.
earch our drug database. drug information and news for professionals and consumers.
https://tadalafil1st.online/# tadalafil online no prescription
All trends of medicament. earch our drug database.
All trends of medicament. Drugs information sheet.
cialis us pharmacy
Read information now. Read here.
safe and effective drugs are available. Get here.
https://amoxila.store/ amoxicillin buy canada
Everything about medicine. Learn about the side effects, dosages, and interactions.
Everything about medicine. earch our drug database.
https://zithromaxa.fun/ buy zithromax online with mastercard
Get warning information here. Read here.
Cautions. п»їMedicament prescribing information.
25 mg prednisone
earch our drug database. earch our drug database.
I have read your article carefully and I agree with you very much. This has provided a great help for my thesis writing, and I will seriously improve it. However, I don’t know much about a certain place. Can you help me?
This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. “드라마카지노”
I’ve joined your feed and look forward to looking for more of your wonderful
post. Additionally, I’ve shared your site in my social networks
You need to be a part of a contest for one of the most useful sites
해외스포츠중계 online. I most certainly will recommend this site!
ed dysfunction treatment buy ed pills online best ed pill
pain meds online without doctor prescription: natural ed medications – how to cure ed naturally