Wikipedia’s search engine dominance = informational homogeneity?

Nicholas Carr (of “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” fame) is a consistent source of thought-provoking but (in my view) off-base critiques of the information age in general and Wikipedia in particular. He has an interesting post on the Britannica Blog, “All Hail the Information Triuvirate“. This coincides with Britannica’s roll out of new features to invite readers to suggest improvements, and some of the usual impotent snipes from Robert McHenry and other Britannica editors. Wikipedia gets 97% of all encyclopedia traffic on the Internet, so they have little to do but whine about the culture that let this happen and/or try to learn from Wikipedia’s success.

A favorite tactic of Wikipedia critics is to bemoan Wikipedia’s search engine success. Carr demonstrates Wikipedia’s dominance of results from the most popular search engine (Google), showing that for ten diverse searches that he first ran in August 2006, then again in December 2007, and again this month, Wikipedia articles rose from an average of placement of #4 to being the #1 hit for all ten searches. Carr “wonder[s] if the transformation of the Net from a radically heterogeneous information source to a radically homogeneous one is a good thing” and has difficulty imagining “that Wikipedia articles are actually the very best source of information for all of the many thousands of topics on which they now appear as the top Google search result.” But this rings shallow without examples (say, for any of his ten searches) of what single web pages would be better starting points.

The idea that the Net has become “radically homogeneous” just because Wikipedia is often the first Google hit is absurd. Wikipedia itself is far from homogeneous, and indeed its great strength is the way it brings together the good parts of many of the other sources of information on the Internet (and beyond). Carr’s implication seems to be that without Wikipedia (the “path of least resistance” for information delivery) search results would be better and finding valuable web content would be easier.

Carr seems to conceive of Wikipedia as a filter placed over Google that lets through only a homogeneous mediocrity. Wikipedia is better thought of as refined version of Google’s method of harnessing the heterogeneity of the Internet; where Google relies on a purely mechanical process, Wikipedia brings together sources with consideration of the individual topic at hand and human evaluation of the importance and reliability of each source.

18 thoughts on “Wikipedia’s search engine dominance = informational homogeneity?”

  1. Wikipedia is the first in Google because its articles are the best on average, thus it is easier and cheaper (both for a search algorithm and a human reader) to identify them as (mostly) high quality than to assess the quality of individual pages. This is the very point of an encyclopedia (EB is not the best book for all topics, actually, it is probably not the best for any of them; but it is better for the most topics than any single book), so it is a bit strange to read this lamentation on information homogenity on the EB blog, of all places. They didn’t have any problems with it while they were the top suppliers of homogenized information…

    1. “Wikipedia is the first in Google because its articles are the best on average”

      I think this assertion is seriously wrong, regardless of the quality of Wikipedia articles. Even if the articles are good, which they often are, THE reason why Wikipedia is first in Google is simply because most bloggers and journalists are too lazy to do what Wikipedia itself suggest (“quote several primary sources”).

      They just add a link to Wikipedia. it’s the number of links given to Wikipedia even when a primary source exist that makes its pages first. That’s why I added lazy quoting of Wikipedia to my 2010 Online Loser Guide at http://stop.zona-m.net/node/66 (which also includes links to Wikipedia policies on quoting sources).

  2. Hey,

    I hope this email finds you well. I wanted to let you know about our new BANGE backpacks and sling bags that just released.

    The bags are waterproof and anti-theft, and have a built-in USB cable that can recharge your phone while you’re on the go.

    Both bags are made of durable and high-quality materials, and are perfect for everyday use or travel.

    Order yours now at 50% OFF with FREE Shipping: https://bangeshop.com

    Enjoy,

    Heike

  3. Do you have time to brush your dog’s teeth every day?

    Let your dog clean his own teeth with our dog dental care brushing stick. Made of eco-friendly natural rubber, this toothbrush is sturdy. The soft design is safe for your dogs’ gums and helps to clean their teeth and protect them from oral diseases and dental decay.

    Act Now And Receive A Special Discount!

    Click here: https://dogcare.center

    Kind Regards,

    Alisha

  4. World’s Best Neck Massager Get it Now 50% OFF + Free Shipping!

    Wellness Enthusiasts! There has never been a better time to take care of your neck pain!
    Our clinical-grade TENS technology will ensure you have neck relief in as little as 20 minutes.

    Get Yours: https://hineck.shop

    To your success,

    Florian
    ragesoss – assorted blogging by Sage Ross

  5. World’s Best Neck Massager Get it Now 50% OFF + Free Shipping!

    Wellness Enthusiasts! There has never been a better time to take care of your neck pain!
    Our clinical-grade TENS technology will ensure you have neck relief in as little as 20 minutes.

    Get Yours: https://hineck.shop

    Thank You,

    Tod
    ragesoss – assorted blogging by Sage Ross

  6. Hey

    I wanted to reach out and let you know about our new dog harness. It’s really easy to put on and take off – in just 2 seconds – and it’s personalized for each dog.
    Plus, we offer a lifetime warranty so you can be sure your pet is always safe and stylish.

    We’ve had a lot of success with it so far and I think your dog would love it.

    Get yours today with 50% OFF: https://caredogbest.com

    FREE Shipping – TODAY ONLY!

    The Best,

    Johanna

  7. Hi there

    I wanted to reach out and let you know about our new dog harness. It’s really easy to put on and take off – in just 2 seconds – and it’s personalized for each dog.
    Plus, we offer a lifetime warranty so you can be sure your pet is always safe and stylish.

    We’ve had a lot of success with it so far and I think your dog would love it.

    Get yours today with 50% OFF: https://caredogbest.com

    FREE Shipping – TODAY ONLY!

    Thanks and Best Regards,

    Kraig

  8. Hi,

    Do you ever worry about your belongings when you travel? I know I do. Our Sling Bags are drop-proof, anti-theft, scratch-resistant, and come with a USB charging port. They’re perfect for keeping your belongings safe when you’re on the go.

    I think these would make an excellent addition to your travel gear. I’m confident you’ll love them as much as I do.

    50% OFF for the next 24 Hours ONLY + FREE Worldwide Shipping for a LIMITED time

    Buy now: https://fashiondaily.shop

    Best Wishes,
    Zenaida

  9. Hi there

    Is your dog’s nails getting too long? If you’re tired of going to the vet or groomer to get them trimmed, why not try PawSafer™?
    With PawSafer™, you can trim your dog’s nails from the comfort of your own home, and it only takes a few minutes!

    PawSafer™ is the safest and most convenient way to trim your dog’s nails, and it’s very affordable.

    Get it while it’s still 50% OFF + FREE Shipping

    Buy here: https://pawsafer.sale

    Thank You,

    Alonzo

  10. Hey

    Is your dog’s nails getting too long? If you’re tired of going to the vet or groomer to get them trimmed, why not try PawSafer™?
    With PawSafer™, you can trim your dog’s nails from the comfort of your own home, and it only takes a few minutes!

    PawSafer™ is the safest and most convenient way to trim your dog’s nails, and it’s very affordable.

    Get it while it’s still 50% OFF + FREE Shipping

    Buy here: https://pawsafer.sale

    Thanks and Best Regards,

    Darryl

  11. Morning

    The New Powerful LED Flashlight is The Perfect Flashlight For Any Situation!

    The 3,000 Lumens & Adjustable Zoom gives you the wide field of view and brightness other flashlights don’t have.

    50% OFF + Free Shipping! Get it Now: https://linternaonline.shop

    Many Thanks,

    Cerys

  12. Hey

    The New Powerful LED Flashlight is The Perfect Flashlight For Any Situation!

    The 3,000 Lumens & Adjustable Zoom gives you the wide field of view and brightness other flashlights don’t have.

    50% OFF + Free Shipping! Get it Now: https://linternaonline.shop

    The Best,

    Maxine

  13. Hey,

    If you are one of the sufferers of the common problems nails have, then you are in luck! Our Toenail Clippers is here to help. It has a specially designed clip that can help those with troubles with winding nails, hard nails, two nails, nail cracks, deep nails, and thickened nails.

    We are confident that our Toenail Clippers will provide you with the results you are looking for.

    Get yours today with 60% OFF: https://thepodiatrist.shop

    Enjoy,

    Deborah

  14. Hi there,

    If you are one of the sufferers of the common problems nails have, then you are in luck! Our Toenail Clippers is here to help. It has a specially designed clip that can help those with troubles with winding nails, hard nails, two nails, nail cracks, deep nails, and thickened nails.

    We are confident that our Toenail Clippers will provide you with the results you are looking for.

    Get yours today with 60% OFF: https://thepodiatrist.shop

    Cheers,

    Stephania

  15. New Multifunction Waterproof Backpack

    The best ever SUPER Backpack: Drop-proof/Scratch-resistant/USB Charging/Large capacity storage

    50% OFF for the next 24 Hours ONLY + FREE Worldwide Shipping for a LIMITED time

    Buy now: https://thebackpack.co

    Regards,

    Tanisha

  16. New Multifunction Waterproof Backpack

    The best ever SUPER Backpack: Drop-proof/Scratch-resistant/USB Charging/Large capacity storage

    50% OFF for the next 24 Hours ONLY + FREE Worldwide Shipping for a LIMITED time

    Buy now: https://thebackpack.co

    Best,

    Elena

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *